I'm asking this here, because just about everyone I know who would probably know the answer hangs out here. At least I hope you all still do :)
If I purchase a pattern for something, say a sweater or a skirt or whathaveyou, can the designer put the condition on the copyright that I cannot then sell the product that I have made? To me it seems like reaching. I get not reselling the pattern online, but if I've paid for the instructions, do they really retain the right to decide what I do with something that they didn't make?
I've seen this a couple of times on patterns on ravelry, and I'm thinking that that really can't be enforceable in anyway. Just because you design something doesn't mean that you own all connections to it until the end of time. It's reasonable if you are giving it away - maybe - I'm not up on copyright law - but it would seem to me to be in line with having a school teach you how to do something (run a business, lets say) and then saying afterwards that you can't run a business that makes any money because the knowledge you now have is copyrighted to them.
Thoughts?
If I purchase a pattern for something, say a sweater or a skirt or whathaveyou, can the designer put the condition on the copyright that I cannot then sell the product that I have made? To me it seems like reaching. I get not reselling the pattern online, but if I've paid for the instructions, do they really retain the right to decide what I do with something that they didn't make?
I've seen this a couple of times on patterns on ravelry, and I'm thinking that that really can't be enforceable in anyway. Just because you design something doesn't mean that you own all connections to it until the end of time. It's reasonable if you are giving it away - maybe - I'm not up on copyright law - but it would seem to me to be in line with having a school teach you how to do something (run a business, lets say) and then saying afterwards that you can't run a business that makes any money because the knowledge you now have is copyrighted to them.
Thoughts?